Broadway Review: “American Psycho” Teases the Psyche at the Gerald Schoenfeld Theatre

David Roberts

  • OnStage Chief New York Theatre Critic

Change one letter in the phrase ‘American Psycho’ to form a phrase that describes the essence of Roberto Aguirre-Sacasa/Duncan Sheik’s musical currently playing at the Gerald Schoenfeld Theatre - a phrase that handily explains why the musical garnered such praise on the London stage. The result: ‘American Psyche.” Brits love watching the foibles of their “children across the pond” play out on the stage – especially antics that arise from the specific character of the American experience. Certainly the final year of the 1980s provides a plethora of deadly sins and detritus from the opening of Pandora’s box/jar. Think “Enron” on steroids.

Roberto Aguirre-Sacasa’s book brims with the excesses of 1989 America and these come into sharp focus in the character of the protagonist Patrick Bateman (Benjamin Walker) and the coterie of mindless and vapid individuals he surrounds himself with including his girlfriend Evelyn Williams (Helene Yorke); his best friend Timothy Price (Theo Stockman); and his co-workers Craig McDermott (Alex Michael Stoll), David Van Patten (Dave Thomas Brown), and Luis Carruthers (Jordan Dean). 

Mergers and acquisitions analyst Patrick Bateman barely hangs on to reality and his coping mechanisms dwindle as his ego strength wanes. The “existential horror” that is America resonates with a similar horror that haunts his psyche resulting in a spate of “murders and executions” that appear to be more matters of fantasy than acts of reality. It is clear that what haunts the young, ripped, and handsome analyst is the same dystopian future facing the nation itself.

Were it not for Benjamin Walker’s formidable craft, “American Psycho” would be as much of a horror as Mr. Aguirre-Sacsa’s weak and shallow book – this musical is pure comic book and more anime than theatre. And Duncan Skeik’s music and lyrics are equally unsatisfactory. As syrupy as Patrick’s secretary Jean’s (Jennifer Damiano) love ballad “A Girl Before” is, under Ms. Damiano’s care, it far outshines the majority of the musical numbers. 

Other exceptions are the numbers sung by Benjamin Walker who brings as much honesty to his character Patrick Bateman as possible. “Common Man,” “The End of an Island” (with Ms. Damiano), and “This Is Not an Exit” stand out in the list of some twenty-two musical numbers.

Photo: Benjamin Walker as Patrick Bateman. Credit: Jeremy Daniel

Photo: Benjamin Walker as Patrick Bateman. Credit: Jeremy Daniel

Like Hans Christian Andersen’s delusional Emperor, Patrick Bateman is depicted most of the time in some state of near-nudity. And although Benjamin Walker pulls that task off well, it does not fully justify the overuse of that trope that is meant to highlight the ignorance, incompetence, and boorishness of contemporary American society. 

“American Psycho” is worth the visit to see Mr. Walker’s electrifying performance – suited up or strutting around in bloodied underwear in the second act’s extended “dream” sequence – and to allow his Patrick Bateman to rattle the recesses of the American psyche within and outside the theatre.

“American Psycho” has music direction by Jason Hart, and music supervision and vocal arrangements by David Shrubsole.

The cast of “American Psycho” features Krystina Alabado, Dave Thomas Brown, Jennifer Damiano, Jordan Dean, Anna Eilinsfeld, Jason Hite, Ericka Hunter, Holly James, Brandon Kalm, Drew Moerlein, Sydney Morton, Alice Ripley, Anthony Sagaria, Keith Randolph Smith, Theo Stockman, Alex Michael Stoll, Benjamin Walker, Morgan Weed, Helene Yorke, and Neka Zang.   

“American Psycho has scenic design by Es Devlin, costume design by Katrina Lindsay lighting design by Justin Townsend, sound design by Dan Moses Schreier, and video design by Finn Ross Casting is by Telsey + Company/Craig Burns, CSA. Production photos by Jeremy Daniel.

The regular performance schedule for “American Psycho” is:  Monday, Tuesday and Thursday at 7:00 p.m.; Friday at 8:00 p.m.; Saturday at 2:00 p.m. and 8:00 p.m.; and Sunday at 2:00 p.m. and 7:00 p.m. Wednesdays are dark (please visit for variations to this schedule).
Tickets for “American Psycho” are priced $69.00 - $148.00 ($225.00 - $250.00 for premium seating) and are available via or by phone at (212) 239-6200. Running time is 2 hours and 30 minutes with a 15-minute intermission.