Kevin Lynch’s “George Floyd the Musical” Draws Criticism After Casting Call Appears on Playbill

by Chris Peterson

A casting call for George Floyd the Musical was listed on Playbill’s jobs board this week and has since been removed. Playbill also posted about the listing on Instagram.

There’s some question about how the job posting even made it on Playbill’s jobs board, but honestly, that’s not really an issue. They made a mistake and quickly corrected it while apologizing for it. There’s no story as far as Playbill’s process goes.

The bigger story is, of course, who is behind the George Floyd Musical, and when we heard about this, we had a pretty good idea who it was, and yes, it was Kevin Lynch.

This posting is from the catalog of Busted Broadway,  Lynch’s musical theatre recording label. In March of this year, Playwrights Horizons settled a lawsuit brought by Lynch over a ticket discount for a BIPOC Night performance of Practice. In June of this year, Lynch filed a lawsuit over Wicked’s Music Director Experience, alleging that the program’s eligibility rules for applying to be a music director prevent white males from applying.

Lynch was looking for people to understand what it was like for him to read a theatre opportunity and be excluded because of the eligibility requirements. Now, I’m looking for even one sentence in the pitch for George Floyd: The Musical in which Lynch considers the experience of a Black actor auditioning for the project to sing comedy for $150 a day. 

The label is a “creative sandbox” for Lynch to explore musical titles that “should never, EVER, be staged given their subject matter.” That’s a lot of shock value for a grown man, and it reminds me of the kid in rehearsal who would say something really ugly and then wait for everyone to turn around to see if they were shocked. 

This is where this story ultimately becomes a teachable moment for us all, because, believe me, OnStage Blog doesn’t want to give Kevin Lynch any more free publicity. In fact, we debated even publishing an editorial because that’s probably exactly what Lynch wants. 

But there is something instructive in this episode for us.

Broadway and regional theatres have provocateurs; we just interviewed one in Andrew Fox for the podcast. But everyone whose work makes it onto a prominent stage demonstrates actual talent to get there. Trey Parker and Matt Stone are wildly offensive and insensitive by design, but they demonstrated an incredible gift for writing music and lyrics before writing The Book of Mormon. You can say the same thing for Andrew Fox before Slam Frank. 

What exactly has Kevin Lynch demonstrated? That he’s a halfway decent right-wing troll? Congratulations, I’m sure Tucker Carlson will be happy to have you on his next podcast. 

But no Broadway producer is going to have him on their stage until he demonstrates he should be taken seriously as a lyricist or composer. And frankly, neither should we. 

I don’t know if Lynch has written a very funny number about the executives who spent the summer of 2020 working on racial justice statements while their Black employees waited for raises. But that would be something to listen to. Instead, the singer is given George Floyd’s name, the request for comedic singers, and the label’s disclaimer about its taste for outrageous material. The singer has to supply whatever charitable interpretation makes them comfortable getting in the car.

Now, Kevin, you have my attention. I’d be happy to write more about what you’ve written. Pick a joke from the album that you’re proud of. Put your name next to it, the way you’re asking performers to put theirs in the credits, and tell us why you needed George Floyd to make it work.

Next
Next

Central Texas Theatre Postpones Jagged Little Pill. Some Cast and Crew Want the Board to Resign.